SmallOneEyedKing: You really know how to use thumbnails effectively

ValeofWoe: Great thumbnail

iwishihadgoodinternet7766: lack of crossplay hurts

unless one platform absolutely blows up in player count ( i have a ps5 and pc), I'll pass on this one sadly

noahmora6720: As mentioned towards the end of the video, the addition of more content down the line will increase the ability to replay it more. It's a little bit of a gamble or investment depending how you see it but can easily turn into a Helldivers situation where there it just refuses to die

johnhuddleston1986: Unfortunately, this isnt how I like to enjoy my souls combat. Hope everyone has fun though.

jjstraka1982: I've never been presented with a single compelling argument for why I should care about recycled assets. I have been fighting the same rats in every one of their games since climbing up to the Undead Burg and it's never bothered me for a solitary second. Other than the fact that I hate rats and From makes the most repulsive looking animal creatures in gaming (this is a compliment).

someguythatdoesstuff7658: Bro was edging us with the thumbnail

LordSensei_Izanagi: Ironeye mains lets get this bread

totalrko: No Cross-Play, no possibility to play in duo and the fact that solo play is basically impossible killed my interest tbh.

KingKalzak: I feel like an 8.7 is a very fair rating! Nice work man

andreichetan4694: Pass for me. I would have loved an optimized solo

Run. My friends didn’t even finish the main game dlc

bruhmomento4946: "its seemingly cannon" no they specifically said its not cannon when it was announced there is 0 speculation to be had

tylerd4039: So hyped. I enjoyed the beta and played each window start to finish. Can’t wait to play it with friends

ShannaDuncan-v4x: This is gonna be so much fun. I absolutely love Elden Ring and to immerse myself in it for hours and hours, but I also struggle periodically with a less than optimal attention span due to my silly brain. But often in those periods of time, I still want to play Elden Ring anyway, even if I know that I'll not be able to fully enjoy the game the way I would like due to this issue. Nightreign will absolutely fix that for me. Short game sessions for those times that I lack the attention span for the full Elden Ring experience, but still want my Elden Ring fix. Probably going to mostly play solo, even if it's gonna be challenging, that does not bother me at all. Almost feels like FromSoft made this game for me. Thank you for this spoilerfree review, this is how reviews are done properly.

ScottPetrie-e2r: Waiting for this review!! Cheers for the excellent video as always

DeathsInverse: Maybe wrong place to ask but will you guys be covering Tainted Grail?

dziosdzynes7663: Thumbnail is

DdHenley307: I'm probably an outlier but boss fights were pretty low on the list of reasons I think Elden Ring is great

NucklesMcGinty: I’ve heard other reviewers say the “optimization” of the runs eventually make it all just box checking and you’ll end up doing the exact same thing every run to optimize your runs, which sounds dreadful

3ZIO87: Man the thumbnail

darkhavok4226: I'm definitely going to hold off a while and see where this goes

LushezFutbolFacts: im here for the gameplay not for the thumb gasp

Jvrbz: I’d love to see team stats when you’re done, something similar to remnant 2’s boss rush mode

Chhipz: Great review as always - can we please get a Revenant breakdown video, have been dying out here like the spongebob episode where he needs water

GM-xk1nw: Ok, Fextralife is becoming my favorite reviewer.

May 29 2025

Buy Elden Ring Runes